Regulations & funding

Cookies and privacy on a website: consent, the cookie banner and the privacy notice

Non-essential cookies require the user's consent before they are set. A guide to the Finnish regulator Traficom's guidelines, a good cookie banner, analytics and the privacy notice.

Updated

Almost every business website uses cookies: analytics, ad tracking, chat, embedded videos and maps all store information on the visitor's device. In Finland, the use of cookies is regulated by the Act on Electronic Communications Services, and the processing of personal data by the GDPR. The rules have tightened, and Traficom has issued supervisory decisions to several well-known companies over inadequate cookie practices.

This article explains what the rules require and how cookies are handled as part of website maintenance. It is written from a Finnish perspective; the underlying ePrivacy rules are EU-wide, but national interpretations differ.

Who supervises and what does the law say?

In Finland, the use of cookies is supervised by Traficom's National Cyber Security Centre. The legal basis is section 205 of the Act on Electronic Communications Services. Under it, a service provider may store data on a user's terminal device and use it only with the user's consent, and the user must be given clear and comprehensive information about the purpose of storing or using it. Cookies that are necessary to provide the service are an exception.

If cookies are used to process personal data, which is usually the case in analytics and marketing, the GDPR also applies, supervised by the Data Protection Ombudsman.

In addition to cookies, the rules also cover similar technologies, such as the browser's local storage, tracking pixels and device identifiers.

Based on Traficom's guidelines and the case law of the Court of Justice of the EU, consent must be:

  • Freely given: use of the service must not be blocked because the user does not accept non-essential cookies.
  • Active: pre-ticked boxes are not valid consent (the CJEU's Planet49 judgment, C-673/17).
  • Given in advance: non-essential cookies must not be set before consent. A banner that only opens on top of tracking scripts that have already loaded does not meet the requirement.
  • Specific: consent is given separately for different purposes, such as analytics and marketing.
  • Revocable: the user must be able to change their choices and withdraw consent as easily as they gave it.

Traficom changed its position in 2021. Before that, browser cookie settings were considered sufficient consent in Finland, but today they are not.

The same shortcomings recur in Traficom's supervisory decisions. Based on them, a good cookie banner:

  1. Offers equivalent options on the first layer: "Accept all" and "Necessary only" are equally visible. "Accept all" plus "Settings" is not enough.
  2. Sets nothing non-essential before the choice. This must be checked technically, not just from the banner's wording.
  3. Explains the purpose of the cookies clearly: which cookies are used, for what purpose, whether they are first-party or third-party and how long they are kept.
  4. Does not use an "Unclassified" category as an object of consent. Traficom has held that such consent is not specific.
  5. Allows choices to be changed at any time, for example from a link in the footer.
  6. Is accessible and usable with a keyboard. The banner must also not shift the page content when it loads, because that worsens the CLS value.

Analytics without cookies?

Some analytics tools have a mode that uses no cookies and stores nothing on the user's device. Such a solution may not require consent under the Act on Electronic Communications Services, but it must be assessed case by case: processing IP addresses or device data can also be processing of personal data to which the GDPR applies. Data collected without consent is often more limited, so define your analytics needs before choosing a tool.

Embeds and third parties

Many websites set cookies without knowing it. Typical sources are:

  • YouTube and Vimeo embeds
  • map embeds
  • social media feeds and share buttons
  • chat and booking services
  • web fonts and external CDN services.

Good practice is to load an embed only when the user clicks it or has given consent, and to use the services' privacy-enhanced embed options, such as YouTube's youtube-nocookie.com address.

Privacy notice

In addition to the cookie notice, a website needs a privacy notice if it processes personal data, for example through a contact form, a newsletter subscription, an online shop or analytics. The privacy notice explains, among other things:

  • the controller and contact details
  • the purposes and legal bases of processing
  • the data processed and its sources
  • the recipients, such as the hosting provider and analytics and email services
  • transfers of data outside the EU and EEA
  • retention periods, including for backups
  • the rights of data subjects.

Cookies on the maintenance checklist

The cookie situation changes whenever a plugin, embed or marketing tool is added to the site. Add these to maintenance:

  • Quarterly: a cookie scan compared with the cookie notice. New cookies are classified and described.
  • When introducing a new tool: check which cookies it sets and whether it only loads after consent.
  • Annually: check that the privacy notice, service providers and transfers are up to date.
  • Technically: use the browser's developer tools to check that no non-essential cookies or requests occur before consent.

Cookies are also linked to accessibility requirements and to the site's security, because third-party scripts are also a security risk.

Frequently asked questions

Does Google Analytics require cookie consent?

Yes. According to Traficom's position, cookies for visitor tracking and analytics are not strictly necessary, so they require the user's consent before they are set. The same applies to other similar tracking technologies, such as the browser's local storage and tracking pixels.

Is it enough that users can block cookies in their browser settings?

Not any more. In Finland, browser settings used to be considered sufficient consent, but Traficom changed its position in 2021. Under the current position, non-essential cookies require active consent within the service.

Can a cookie banner have only an Accept all button?

No. According to Traficom's supervisory decisions, refusing cookies must be as easy as accepting them. In practice, the first layer of the banner must include an equally visible option for accepting only the necessary cookies.

Which cookies are strictly necessary?

Strictly necessary cookies are those needed to provide a service explicitly requested by the user or to transmit a message. Examples include the shopping cart, login, security and storing the user's cookie choices. Analytics, advertising, personalisation and social media embeds are not strictly necessary.

Sources

  1. Traficom: Cookies and other data stored on users' terminal devices – guide for service providers (in Finnish)
  2. Traficom: supervisory decision on cookies (Nordea Bank Oyj, in Finnish)
  3. Office of the Data Protection Ombudsman (Finland)
  4. Court of Justice of the EU: Planet49 (C-673/17)